Pre-Adverse vs. Adverse Action Notices: Employer Compliance

Effective hiring practices require more than just finding the right candidate—it demands adherence to fair and legal processes, particularly when conducting background checks. Employers must carefully follow federal and state laws, such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), to ensure compliance. Among the key requirements under the FCRA are the proper use of pre-adverse and adverse action notices. Understanding the difference between these notices is critical to reducing risks, maintaining compliance, and protecting the rights of applicants.

What Are Pre-Adverse and Adverse Action Notices?

When employers use information obtained in a background check to make hiring decisions, they may encounter negative findings. The FCRA mandates a two-step process in such cases, requiring the issuance of pre-adverse and adverse action notices to the candidate.

Pre-Adverse Action Notices

A pre-adverse action notice is a formal communication sent to inform a candidate that the information in their background check report may lead to an adverse hiring decision. This notice gives the candidate the opportunity to review the report and dispute any inaccuracies before a final decision is made. It must include the following elements:

• A copy of the background check report.
• A copy of the FCRA Summary of Rights.

By providing this notice, employers uphold the candidate’s right to review and correct potential errors in their report.

Adverse Action Notices

If, after considering a candidate’s response to the pre-adverse notice, the employer decides to move forward with an adverse hiring decision, the candidate must receive an adverse action notice. This final communication informs the candidate of the decision and their continued rights under the law. It typically includes:

• A statement of the adverse decision made.
• Details about the consumer reporting agency (CRA) that supplied the report (including contact information).
• A reminder of their rights to dispute the accuracy of the report with the CRA and to request a free copy of their file within 60 days.

When Should Each Notice Be Sent?

Step 1: Pre-Adverse Action Notice Timing

Employers must send the pre-adverse notice as soon as they identify a background check issue that might result in a negative hiring decision. Importantly, there must be a reasonable waiting period following this notice—typically five business days—allowing candidates the opportunity to respond or dispute the findings.

Step 2: Adverse Action Notice Timing

Only after the waiting period, and after thoroughly considering any disputes raised by the candidate, can the employer issue an adverse action notice. Skipping or incorrectly timing this process can result in legal and financial penalties.

Compliance Steps Under the FCRA and State Laws

Employers operating in the complex regulatory landscape of background checks must diligently follow compliance requirements. Key steps include:

1. Understand State-Specific Laws – Some states, like California, impose additional disclosure and timing requirements beyond the FCRA.
2. Provide Accurate and Clear Notices – Ensure both pre-adverse and adverse action notices include all legally required information.
3. Allow Sufficient Time for Disputes – Respect the candidate’s right to dispute inaccuracies. Five business days is a common standard, but state laws may vary.
4. Document Every Step – Maintain thorough records of notifications, candidate communications, and decisions. Proper documentation is critical for defending your process if challenged.
5. Work with Trusted Screening Partners – A reputable CRA can help ensure compliance and minimize the risk of background check errors.

Why Compliance Matters

Failing to follow pre-adverse and adverse action notice protocols can lead to severe consequences. Penalties for non-compliance include costly lawsuits, reputational damage, and regulatory fines. Adhering to FCRA and state-specific requirements demonstrates your organization’s commitment to fair hiring practices and helps foster trust with candidates.

How Plexus Global Can Support Employers

Navigating the intricacies of background screening and compliance can be overwhelming, but expert guidance can simplify the process. Plexus Global partners with employers to provide compliant, accurate, and efficient background screening solutions tailored to your hiring needs.

Ready to strengthen your workforce with smarter, safer screening practices?

Plexus Global helps employers across California and the U.S. navigate background screening with clarity, compliance, and confidence.